|
|
||||||||
Articles |
Departments of
1
Laboratory Medicine and
2
Gynaecology, Karl Franzens University, Graz, Austria.
a Address correspondence to this author, at: Blocklabor II, Auenbruggerplatz 15, 8036 Graz, Austria. Fax 0316/385/3430.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key Words: indexing terms: chromatography, liquid immunoassay intermethod comparison variation, source of hemoglobin variants
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Besides method-dependent interferences, interlaboratory standardization and harmonization present problems, since no stable standards exist for use with different types of assays. Accordingly, multicenter studies are difficult to carry out, and direct comparison of results from different locations is not reliable (14)(15).
Here we describe the evaluation of three newly introduced Hb A1c assay systems, in comparison with the Diamat HPLC (Bio-Rad Labs., Hercules, CA) method (15).
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
procedures
Venous blood was collected into EDTA-containing evacuated
collection tubes and kept at 4 °C until analysis (within 5 days
after collection). All Hb A1c analyses were performed
at the University of Graz Department of Laboratory Medicine (II) with
use of the Diamat HPLC, the Variant HPLC (Bio-Rad Labs.), the Hi-Auto
A1c analyzer system HA-8140 (Menarini Diagnostics,
Florence, Italy), and a Roche immunoassay (UNIMATE Hb A1c
reagents used with a COBAS MIRA analyzer system; Hoffmann-La Roche,
Basel, Switzerland).
Fructosamine was determined in serum by a nitroblue tetrazolium colorimetric procedure (Hoffmann-La Roche) on the COBAS MIRA. The reference interval, determined in our laboratory, is <285 µmol/L.
Preprandial serum glucose concentrations were determined by a hexokinase/glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase assay without deproteinization, performed with a Hitachi 747 (all from Boehringer-Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany). The reference interval is 3.927.28 mmol/L in our laboratory.
hb a1c assays
Diamat HPLC.
Whole-blood samples are hemolyzed in a
borate-containing buffer, which promotes dissociation of labile Hb
A1c. This reaction is enhanced by a 30-min incubation at
37 °C. Further sample processing is performed automatically. For
chromatographic separation, a step gradient of three phosphate buffers
with increasing ionic strengths is used. Results are generated as %Hb
A1c or as %Hb A (a+b+c). Analysis time is 5
min per sample. The reference interval is 4.36.1%, determined in our
laboratory (7).
Variant HPLC.
This fully automated Hb analyzer,
developed specifically for determining Hb A1c in human
blood, uses ion-exchange HPLC. First, samples are diluted with lysing
reagent (citrate solution, pH 5.0, containing <0.5 g/L sodium azide as
preservative) and then incubated at room temperature for 10 min to
hemolyze the blood and remove labile Hb A1c. Further sample
processing is performed automatically. The samples are injected into
the analytical flow path and applied to a cation-exchange column that
binds Hb. The Hb components are chromatographically separated by
programed washing with a buffer gradient of increasing ionic strength.
The separated Hb then passes through the flow cell of the filter
photometer, which measures absorbance at 415 nm and monitors the
changes in absorbance; background variations are corrected by use of an
additional filter at 690 nm. Labile Hb A1c does not
interfere, and analysis time is 3 min per sample.
Hi-Auto A
1c analyzer system. The
principle of the analysis is cation-exchange and reversed-phase
chromatography. The whole sample processing is performed automatically.
The analyzer is equipped with a cap-piercing system for direct sampling
of whole blood from a closed primary tube. The Autosampler makes it
possible to test a virtually unlimited number of samples in the same
test session. The system can run whole-blood samples or prehemolyzed
samples alternately without operator adjustment of the instrument.
Samples of whole blood are first diluted by the Autosampler with
hemolysis wash solution, which chemically removes the labile Hb
A1c component. The hemolysate is transferred to a column,
where it is separated by HPLC into Hb Alab, Hb F, Hb
A1c, Hb A0, and various pathological fractions.
Hb A1c is expressed as a percentage of the summed
physiological hemoglobins only. These Hb fractions are separated by
electrostatic interactions with the gel. The hard gel packed in the
column consists of porous beads of copolymers of methacrylic acid and
methacrylate ester; thus, the surface of the gel has hydrophobic groups
and ion-exchange groups. The Hb fractions are eluted by varying the pH
of the mobile phase and are measured photometrically (main wavelength
415 nm, reference wavelength 500 nm). Analysis time is 4 min per
sample.
Roche immunoassay.
The whole sample processing is
performed automatically. The test system combines a latex-enhanced
competitive turbidimetric immunoassay for determining Hb
A1c in whole blood with a colorimetric assessment of total
Hb. First, erythrocytes are lysed by exposure to low osmotic pressure,
after which the Hb is proteolytically transformed to make the
ß-N-terminal available for the competitive immunoassay. The
ß-N-terminal of Hb binds the monoclonal antibody carried by
nonagglutinating latex particles. Free (residual unbound to Hb)
latex-bound antibodies agglutinate with a synthetic polymer that
carries copies of the ß-N-terminal, and the turbidity of these
agglutinates is measured. This competitive immunoassay gives nonlinear
results; i.e., the differences in absorbance are smaller than the
increases in Hb A1c concentrations. Total Hb concentrations
are measured in a cyanide-free colorimetric assay, according to the
formation of alkaline hematin in basic detergent solution.
Concentrations of total Hb are measured by their absorbance at 550 nm.
The test result is then calculated from the Hb A1c/Hb
ratio. The formula for calculation of %Hb A1c contains a
conversion factor to make the results comparable with those by HPLC;
this factor is installed (as a default) by the manufacturer but can be
changed by the user. Analysis time is 2 min per sample.
control materials
To assess within-run imprecision, we prepared whole-blood pools
with low, medium, and high Hb A1c contents and
analyzed the pools (1416 replicates) in 1 day. Total imprecision was
determined with commercially available control blood (supported or
recommended by the manufacturers) of low and high Hb A1c
content by repeated analysis on 20 operating days. The control
materials used were: Recipe level 1 and level 2 for Diamat HPLC;
Lyphochec Glycated Hemoglobin Control (whole blood) level 1 and 2 for
Variant HPLC; Glyco Hb Control level 1 and level 2 for HI-Auto
A1c; and Hb A1c Control N and P for Roche
immunoassay.
statistical methods
The between-methods correlations of Hb A1c values
were determined by linear regression analysis. Differences were
compared by Wilcoxon Sign Rank Test. P <0.05 was considered
statistically significant.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
For method comparison, we assayed all 335 samples with all four
methods. In the nondiabetic patients group, the three new analyzers
gave results significantly different from the results obtained with
Diamat HPLC (P <0.001); in addition, the values determined
with the Variant HPLC and Hi-Auto A1c analyzer were
similar. In the diabetic patients, the three analyzer systems gave
significantly lower Hb A1c values than the Diamat HPLC
results (P <0.03) but did not vary significantly among
themselves. To determine the correlations between the different
analyzer systems, we used the results for all samples except those with
hemoglobin variants. The correlation coefficients from comparing
Variant HPLC, Hi-Auto A1c analyzer system, and Roche
immunoassay with the Diamat HPLC were 0.97, 0.98, and 0.97,
respectively (Fig. 1
).
|
To detect possible interferences, we analyzed selected samples with
anemia (n = 33), polycythemia (n = 25), or high titers of
rheumatoid factor (n = 10) and samples from patients undergoing
hemodialysis because of end-stage renal failure (n = 22). To
detect systemic effects, we calculated the mean residual value of each
data pair, i.e., the y-axis distance from the point
delineated by the data pair to the regression line. No statistically
significant interferences were evident (Fig. 2
).
|
Results for the samples containing Hb variants (Table 4
)
were as follows:
|
Hb Graz (n = 5).
In the three HPLC assay systems,
all five cases of this Hb variant gave extremely high Hb
A1c values. Only the Hi-Auto A1c analyzer
declared the chromatogram as showing "abnormal separation." The
Roche immunoassay analyzer gave results within or below the reference
interval. In two of the five Hb Graz cases, fructosamine concentrations
exceeded the reference interval; the concentrations in the other three
were normal. HPLC chromatograms of a representative patient with Hb
Graz are shown in Fig. 3
.
|
Hb Sherwood Forest (n = 1).
This Hb variant
gave an extremely high Hb A1c result in the Diamat assay
system. The Variant HPLC divided the peak into two parts labeled
"Unknown 1" and "Unknown 2." The Hi-Auto A1c
analyzer system remarked "Abnormal separation," as with Hb Graz.
The Hb A1c value obtained with the Roche immunoassay
analyzer was within the reference interval, which was in accordance
with the fructosamine concentration.
Hb O-Padova (n = 1).
This Hb variant ordinarily
elutes within the A0 fraction by HPLC. Both Diamat HPLC and
the Hi-Auto A1c analyzer divided the A0 peak
into two parts, but only the Hi-Auto A1c analyzer declared
this to be a Hb variant; no warning was given by the Variant HPLC. The
values obtained by HPLC were within the reference interval in two cases
(Diamat HPLC and Variant HPLC) and above-normal in one case (Hi-Auto
A1c). The Hb A1c proportion measured by the
Roche immunoassay analyzer system was high, as was the fructosamine
concentration.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
An explanation for this discrepancy might be that "gHb" contains various distinct molecules (6), which are measured differently by different methods (11). In addition, negatively charged Hb can interfere more or less (13), and uremia, anemia, and polycythemia can result in falsely high or falsely low values for Hb A1c (11)(13)(25). In our study we saw no significant influence of rheumatoid factor, anemia, polycythemia, or chronic hemodialysis on the Hb A1c values in any of the assay systems investigated, although Hb A1c values measured by Variant HPLC showed a wider range of the residuals for the samples from patients needing chronic hemodialysis than did the other methods. In the Hi-Auto A1c analyzer system a wider range of the residuals of Hb A1c values was observed in samples from patients with polycythemia. This difference was not statistically significant, but it still exceeded the medically allowable error, 1%Hb A1c (e.g., from 9.5% to 10.5% Hb A1c (24)), and in individual patients could cause interpretative problems for clinicians. Thus, in an individual case, the %Hb A1c value might change by >2%Hb A1c because of these interferences. This might result in a wrong diagnostic classification of the patient and cause unnecessary therapeutic interventions (24).
That various methods for Hb A1c measurements show different values for Hb variants is well known (22)(25) and can cause problems in the monitoring of diabetic patients. To overcome this, one should use a method that meets the following conditions: The Hb variant should be recognized; and Hb A1c, Hb A0, and Hb variants should be separated and quantified reliably (25). In HPLC methods, most investigated Hb variants can be recognized by looking at the chromatogram. Only the Hi-Auto analyzer system denotes all such chromatograms as abnormal separations or as showing a Hb variant. The Diamat HPLC showed an abnormal chromatogram, but gave no warning. The Variant HPLC, which characterized only Hb Sherwood Forest as "Unknown," showed an abnormal chromatogram of samples with Hb Graz without warning; its chromatogram for the sample with Hb O-Padova appeared normal and no warning was given. This could lead to problems in cases where the Hb variant gives plausible %Hb A1c values.
As is known for immunoassays (25), the Roche immunoassay
analyzer system does not recognize Hb variants. The user of such
systems thus has no possibility of controlling the accuracy of the
measured %Hb A1c values. According to the corresponding
fructosamine concentrations, the Hb A1c values given by the
Roche immunoassay analyzer system would be falsely low in two of five
cases of Hb Graz. Hb Sherwood Forest is a mutation in position 104 of
the ß-chain (17). Because the Hb is proteolytically
degraded in the first step of the immunoassay and the ß-N-terminal
structure does not differ from that for normal Hb (17), no
interference of Hb A1c determination in the Roche
immunoassay analyzer system would be expected, as was the case in our
patient. The accordance of the %Hb A1c value given by this
system with fructosamine values support this hypothesis. Also, Hb
O-Padova, an
-chain variation (19), gave %Hb
A1c values within the reference intervals for two analyzer
systems (Diamat, Variant) and above-normal values in the Hi-Auto and
the Roche immunoassay analyzer systems. These latter two results
corresponded with the sample's fructosamine values. Finally, because
%Hb A1c values in patients with Hb variants may be
influenced by several nonanalytical factors (22) that also
can hamper interpretation of results, it is not surprising that
interpretations of test results are often erroneous. Measurement of
fructosamine may be a suitable alternative for patients with Hb
variants (22).
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2ß22(NA2)His
Leu; a new ß-chain variant observed in four families from southern Austria. Hemoglobin 1992;16:493-501.
[Web of Science][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
Thr. FEBS Lett 1977;83:260-262.
[Web of Science][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
30(B11)Glu
Lys, and a dyserythropoietic anemia with erythroblastic multinuclearity coexisting in the same patient. Blood 1974;44:869-877.
2 30 (B11) Glu
Lys ß2 observed in members of a Turkish family. Hemoglobin 1985;9:621-625.
[Web of Science][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
The following articles in journals at HighWire Press have cited this article:
![]() |
A H Berg and D B Sacks Haemoglobin A1c analysis in the management of patients with diabetes: from chaos to harmony J. Clin. Pathol., September 1, 2008; 61(9): 983 - 987. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. J. Tascona, A. R. Morton, E. B. Toffelmire, D. C. Holland, and E. A. Iliescu Adequacy of Glycemic Control in Hemodialysis Patients With Diabetes Diabetes Care, October 1, 2006; 29(10): 2247 - 2251. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. N. Reeds, K. E. Yarasheski, L. Fontana, W. T. Cade, E. Laciny, A. DeMoss, B. W. Patterson, W. G. Powderly, and S. Klein Alterations in liver, muscle, and adipose tissue insulin sensitivity in men with HIV infection and dyslipidemia Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab, January 1, 2006; 290(1): E47 - E53. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Ahmed, R. Babaei-Jadidi, S. K. Howell, P. J. Thornalley, and P. J. Beisswenger Glycated and Oxidized Protein Degradation Products Are Indicators of Fasting and Postprandial Hyperglycemia in Diabetes Diabetes Care, October 1, 2005; 28(10): 2465 - 2471. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Platek, V. Krogh, A. Micheli, R. Browne, E. Meneghini, S. Sieri, H. J. Schunemann, V. Pala, M. Barba, G. E. Wilding, et al. Serum Fructosamine and Subsequent Breast Cancer Risk: A Nested Case-Control Study in the ORDET Prospective Cohort Study Cancer Epidemiol. Biomarkers Prev., January 1, 2005; 14(1): 271 - 274. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
I. Sakurabayashi, T. Watano, S. Yonehara, K. Ishimaru, K. Hirai, T. Komori, and M. Yagi New Enzymatic Assay for Glycohemoglobin Clin. Chem., February 1, 2003; 49(2): 269 - 274. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Skeie, G. Thue, and S. Sandberg Interpretation of Hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) Values among Diabetic Patients: Implications for Quality Specifications for HbA1c Clin. Chem., July 1, 2001; 47(7): 1212 - 1217. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. J. Beisswenger, S. K. Howell, R. M. ODell, M. E. Wood, A. D. Touchette, and B. S. Szwergold {alpha}-Dicarbonyls Increase in the Postprandial Period and Reflect the Degree of Hyperglycemia Diabetes Care, April 1, 2001; 24(4): 726 - 732. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
L. Bry, P. C. Chen, and D. B. Sacks Effects of Hemoglobin Variants and Chemically Modified Derivatives on Assays for Glycohemoglobin Clin. Chem., February 1, 2001; 47(2): 153 - 163. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. J. Schnedl, R. W. Lipp, M. Trinker, and P. Hopmeier Hemoglobin D [ß 121(GH4)Glu->Gln] Causing Falsely Low and High HbA1c Values in HPLC Clin. Chem., September 1, 1998; 44(9): 1999 - 2000. [Full Text] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |