|
|
||||||||
Articles |
Trp) Associated with Two New Haplotypes and Evidence That apo B-100 (Glu3405
Gln) Diminishes Receptor-mediated Uptake of LDL
1
Gustav Embden-Centre of Biological Chemistry and
2
Department of Internal Medicine, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-University, Theodor Stern-Kai 7, 60590 Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
3
Division of Clinical Chemistry, Department of Medicine,
Albert Ludwigs-University, Hugstetter Strasse 55, 79098 Freiburg,
Germany.
a Author for correspondence. Fax 49-761-270-3444; e-mail maerz{at}mzl200.ukl.uni-freiburg.de
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Gln) has been the only mutation known to cause
ligand-defective apo B-100. Methods: Using temperature gradient gel electrophoresis, we screened 297 unrelated individuals with LDL-cholesterol >1.55 g/L and triglycerides <2.0 g/L for sequence variants of the putative LDL receptor-binding domain of apo B-100.
Results: We found apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) in
21 individuals (7.1%). When extrapolated to the general population,
this corresponds to the highest prevalence of apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) reported to date. Furthermore,
we identified three unrelated carriers (1%) of a silent
substitution (CTG
CTA) affecting the codon for
leucine3350, four carriers (1.3%) of apo B-100
(Glu3405
Gln), and two subjects (0.7%) with apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp). apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) was
assigned to two different, previously unknown haplotypes. The binding,
uptake, and degradation of apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) was
lower than that of normal LDL, but higher than with apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln), implying that the substitution of
Trp3500 for Arg may cause less severe reduction of binding
than the substitution of Gln. LDL from individuals heterozygous for apo
B-100 (Glu3405
Gln) bound to LDL receptors at the same
rate as normal LDL, but was taken up and degraded at
significantly reduced rates, suggesting that domains of apo B-100
involved in binding and uptake do not completely overlap.
Conclusions: In Germany, apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln)
may be more frequent than previously assumed. Both apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) and apo B-100 (Glu3405
Gln)
may contribute to the phenotype of ligand-defective LDL. These variants
will be missed if screening is confined to apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) only.© 1999 American Association
for Clinical Chemistry
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
To date, several point mutations of the putative receptor binding
domain of apo B-100 have been identified
(9)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16). Only three of these mutations have
been shown to produce binding-defective apo B-100 by appropriate
genetic and functional investigations
(9)(11)(12). The first substitution
to be discovered, and apparently the most frequent one, is apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) (9). The other two
substitutions, apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp)
(11) and apo B-100 (Arg3531
Cys)
(12), occur less frequently. The
Arg3531
Cys mutation has been identified in two
families of different ethnic origin (12); in four CAD
patients from the Great Salt Lake Basin area of the US, all of
Caucasian origin (14); in two families in the United Kingdom
(17); and two French individuals (18). Compared
with apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln), the mutation at
codon 3531 is associated with a smaller increase in LDL-C
(12)(17). Consistently, LDL that contained apo
B-100 (Arg3531
Cys) exhibited less reduction of
LDL receptor binding in vitro than did LDL endowed with apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) (12). To date, apo
B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) has been described in just
one family of European origin (11), twice in a mixed Chinese
and Malayan hypercholesterolemic cohort (15), in one family
of Asian descent living in the Glasgow region (11), and in
another nine unrelated individuals from Taiwan (19). The
receptor binding of apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) is
considered similar to that of apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) (11).
The apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) mutation is
observed with an approximate frequency of 1 in 500 to 1 in 700 in
populations of European (Caucasian) origin (20)(21)(22).
Although primary hypercholesterolemia is a common metabolic disorder in
the middle European population, no additional frequent molecular
reasons for binding-defective apo B-100 have yet been discovered.
Hence, many investigators have relied on methods specifically tailored
to detect the Arg3500
Gln substitution
(21)(23)(24)(25)(26)(27)(28)(29)(30) to diagnose FDB. We examined a
2121-bp (codons 31313837) portion of the apo B gene, including the
putative receptor binding region, using PCR and temperature
gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) in 297 unrelated individuals with
primary hypercholesterolemia to search for new genetic variants that
affect the receptor binding of apo B-100. Among these, 21 carriers of
apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) and 2 carriers of apo
B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) were identified, which
indicates a high prevalence of FDB in our area. Another three
individuals revealed a silent substitution that changes the codon for
Leu3350 from CTG to CTA, and four carriers of apo
B-100 (Arg3405
Gln) were identified.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
blood samples
Blood was drawn into tubes containing potassium EDTA
(final concentration, 3.85.0 mmol/L). The blood was centrifuged
(1500g for 30 min at 10 °C). The supernatant plasma was
used for the analysis of lipids and lipoproteins; the white blood cells
were used to extract genomic DNA.
lipids, lipoproteins, and apolipoproteins
Cholesterol and triglycerides were measured enzymatically
with reagents from Roche Diagnostics HDL-cholesterol (HDL-C) was
measured after precipitation of apo B-containing lipoproteins
(31). LDL-C was calculated according to Friedewald et al.
(32), and apo B was measured by kinetic nephelometry, using
the Protein Array System (Beckman Instruments). Lipoprotein(a)
was measured using a commercial immunoradiometric assay (Mercodia
Diagnostics). Between-day CVs were
3.5% for total cholesterol, total
triglycerides, and apo B;
4% for LDL-C; and
5% for HDL-C for the
duration of the study.
dna preparation and oligonucleotides
Genomic DNA was prepared from white blood cells using
"blood PCR" DNA isolation cartridges (Diagen), according to the
manufacturer's instructions. Oligonucleotides were synthesized using
the phosphoramidite method at MWG Biotech. The sequences of the
oligonucleotides and their positions within the amplified region are
given in Table 1
and Fig. 1
, respectively.
|
|
pcr
apo B gene fragments were prepared by PCR in a final
volume of 50 µL containing 0.10.2 µg of genomic DNA, 60 pmol of
oligonucleotide primers, 62.5 mmol/L KCl, 12.5 mmol/L Tris-HCl, pH 8.3,
1.5 mmol/L MgCl2, 50 µmol/L each dNTP, and 1.5
U of Taq DNA polymerase (Amersham Pharmacia). Three different
PCR cycle conditions were used with respect to different annealing
temperatures of primers. Fragments A, B, C, D, G, and H were amplified
with an initial denaturation step of 94 °C for 1 min, followed by
annealing at 55 °C for 1 min and finally extension at 72 °C for 3
min. Fragment F was amplified with an annealing temperature of
58 °C for 1 min and extension at 72 °C for 3 min, and fragment E
was amplifies with extension at 74 °C for 2 min. Each PCR was
initiated by hot start at 95 °C for 3 min, and Taq polymerase was
added at 80 °C before starting cycles.
tgge
Parallel TGGE was performed in a horizontal gel
electrophoresis apparatus from Qiagen. PCR product (4 µL) was mixed
with 4 µL of denaturing buffer [8 mol/L urea, 400 mmol/L
2-(N-morpholino)propanesulfonic acid, pH 8.0, 20
mmol/L EDTA, 0.1 g/L bromphenol blue, 0.1 g/L xylene xyanol
FF]. Before loading, samples were denatured for 5 min at 95 °C and
renatured for 15 min at 50 °C to allow the formation of heteroduplex
molecules; 6µL of each sample was loaded on the gel. The gels
contained 80 g/L acrylamide (at a ratio of acrylamide to
N,N'-methylenebisacrylamide of 60:1), 8 mol/L urea, 20
mmol/L 2-(N-morpholino)propanesulfonic acid, pH 8.0, 1
mmol/L EDTA, and 20 g/L glycerol. The running time was 3 to 4.5 h
(300 V), depending on the length of the amplified product. Silver
staining was performed as described (33). The temperature
gradient was 35 °C to 55 °C (or 50 °C, respectively) and was
oriented parallel to the direction of migration.
dna sequencing
Homoduplex mutant bands were excised from the stained
polyacrylamide gels, which had not been fixed in that case. Gel slices
were incubated in diffusion buffer (0.5 mol/L ammonium acetate, 10
mmol/L magnesium acetate, 1 mmol/L EDTA, pH 8.0, 1 g/L sodium dodecyl
sulfate) at 60 °C for 20 min, followed by 95 °C for 5 min,
and DNA was extracted with a QIAEX II polyacrylamide gel extraction kit
from Qiagen. The purified DNA (5 µL) was reamplified using
Pfu DNA polymerase (Stratagene), buffers recommended by the
manufacturer, and the previously applied PCR conditions. The
reamplification products were electrophoresed in a 20 g/L agarose gel
and cleaned with QIAEX II (Qiagen), according to the manufacturer's
instructions. Sequencing was performed using the ThermoSequenase cycle
sequencing kit (Amersham) with fluorescently labeled primers, according
to the manufacturer's instructions. DNA was electrophoresed in an ALF
DNA Sequencer (Pharmacia Biotech Europe).
apo B GENE HAPLOTYPING
Five apo B gene polymorphisms [signal peptide insertion
(ins) or deletion (del), XbaI (ACT
ACC,
Thr2488
Thr) restriction fragment length
polymorphism (RFLP), MspI (CGG
CAG,
Arg3611
Gln) RFLP, EcoRI (AAA
GAA,
Lys4154
Glu) RFLP, and the 3' hypervariable
region (3'VNTR)], were analyzed. The methods have been described
previously (33)(34), except for the PCR
conditions we used to determine the EcoRI and the
MspI RFLPs. In these cases we used the primer sequences
given in Table 1
and conditions as follows: The reaction volumes were
20 µL and contained 10 pmol of each primer, 80 µmol/L each dNTP,
2040 ng of genomic DNA, and 0.5 U of Taq DNA polymerase. Thirty-five
cycles were performed (denaturation at 95 °C for 0.30 min, annealing
at 60 °C for 1 min, and elongation at 72 °C for 0.15 min). The
PCR products were incubated at 37 °C for 3 h with 10 U of
the respective restriction enzyme and were subsequently analyzed by
electrophoresis in 20 g/L agarose gels.
detection of point mutations by restriction typing
After the sequencing of those DNA fragments producing
irregular patterns on TGGE, we confirmed the presence of the suspected
alleles with PCR and subsequent restriction fragment analysis. The
methods for Arg3500
Gln and
Arg3500
Trp are described elsewhere
(25)(35). The G
A transition
(Leu3350
Leu) creates a PstI
restriction site in fragment C (Table 1
).
Glu3405
Gln was determined by digesting
fragment D, amplified using the primer pair D3-D2. D3 contains a
mismatch (AGtC) that introduces a TaqI site in the mutant
allele.
binding, uptake, and degradation of 125i-labeled ldl
LDL (1.019 < d < 1.063 kg/L) was
isolated using preparative ultracentrifugation (36) and
iodinated using the iodine monochloride method(37). The human skin fibroblasts were from skin
biopsies of normolipidemic individuals. Cells were grown in 24-well
polystyrene plates, and before the experiments, the cells were
preincubated for 40 h in medium containing 100 mL/L human
lipoprotein-deficient serum to up-regulate LDL receptors. The binding,
uptake, and degradation of 125I-labeled LDL were
measured as described by Goldstein et al. (38) with slight
modifications (39). To measure cell surface binding,
lipoproteins were incubated with the cells for 1 h at 4 °C in
DMEM containing 10 mmol/L HEPES. To measure uptake (surface binding
plus internalization) and degradation, cells were incubated for 4
h at 37 °C with 125I-labeled LDL in DMEM
containing 24 mmol/L bicarbonate, pH 7.4. The amount of
125I-labeled material associated with the cells
(binding and internalization) was determined after lysis in 0.3 mmol/L
NaOH. Proteolytic degradation was determined as
125I-labeled trichloroacetic acid-soluble
(non-iodine) material in the conditioned medium.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Gln) and 1.03 °C
(Arg3500
Trp), respectively, suggesting that
they could be distinguished merely by their TGGE pattern. A common
MspI polymorphism that changes amino acid 3611 from Arg
(CGG) to Gln (CAG) (42), and the
Arg3531
Cys mutation at codon 3531 altered the
calculated melting temperature of this fragment as well. Nonetheless,
TGGE was applied in combination with heteroduplex analysis; i.e., each
PCR-amplified product was de- and renatured to allow homo- and
heteroduplex formation. Heteroduplex strands could be easily
distinguished from homoduplex strands.
To evaluate the actual sensitivity of our assay, we sought
documentation of its ability to detect known sequence variations. As
expected, apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln), apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp), apoB-100
(Arg3531
Cys), and the MspI
polymorphism at codon 3611 could be distinguished (Fig. 2
). Samples heterozygous for a particular mutation produced a
characteristic four-band pattern, the faster migrating pair of bands
representing the homoduplexes of the mutant and wild-type strands,
respectively, and the slower migrating pair of bands corresponding to
heteroduplexes of the two alleles. A single homoduplex band halted at
aberrant positions in the gel was observed with DNA from an individual
homozygous for apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln).
Downstream and upstream sequencing of purified and reamplified mutant
homoduplex bands confirmed the respective nucleotide substitutions.
|
We studied samples from 297 unrelated individuals with LDL-C >1.55 g/L
and triglycerides <2.0 g/L. In each of the samples exhibiting
irregular melting behavior, the presence of the suspected mutation was
confirmed through restriction fragment analysis and DNA sequencing
where appropriate. Using this strategy, we identified 21 carriers of
apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) and 2 carriers of apo
B-100 (Arg3500
Trp). Four patients exhibited
aberrant migration of fragment D (Fig. 2
); these subjects were
heterozygous for apo B-100 (Glu3405
Gln). In
three other unrelated individuals, we detected an abnormality of
fragment C (Fig. 2
) attributable to a silent transition that changed
the codon for leucine at position 3350 from CTG to CTA. There was no
carrier of the Arg3531
Cys mutation detected in
our sample. Two of the four mutations, apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) and apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp), recently have been unequivocally
linked to the development of hypercholesterolemia
(11)(20). The frequency of heterozygous apo
B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) carriers was 21 in 297
(7.1%) in the entire patient group and 7 in 128 (5.5%) when we
considered only individuals 4065 years of age. A recent
cross-sectional survey performed at our institutions revealed the
prevalence of type IIa HLP (as defined by LDL-C >1.55 g/L and
triglycerides <2.0 g/L) to be at least 25% among clinically healthy
individuals between the ages of 40 and 65 years (M.A. Nauck et al.,
unpublished results). If we assume that mutant forms of apo B-100
produce type IIa HLP only (which is a conservative estimate because in
some instances patients with FDB exhibit type IIb HLP), the calculated
prevalence of heterozygous ligand-defective apo B-100 would be at least
1.4% (1 in 71) among healthy individuals in the Rhein-Main area.
We were able to recruit 19 family members of 9 of the 21 unrelated apo
B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) carriers. Among these
subjects, 18 were heterozygous and 1 was homozygous for apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln). Using five polymorphic markers
of the apo B gene, we deduced partial haplotypes in all apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) subjects. Consistent with
previous reports (43), they exhibited a consensus haplotype
designated as ins, XbaI-, MspI+,
EcoRI-, 3'VNTR-49 haplotype 194, according to the binary
nomenclature of Ludwig and McCarthy (43). Haplotyping of
carriers of the apo B-100 (Glu3405
Gln)
mutation and of the silent transition at codon 3350 revealed the common
genotypes del, XbaI+, MspI+, EcoRI+,
3'VNTR-37 and ins, XbaI-, MspI+,
EcoRI+, 3'VNTR-35, respectively (Table 2
). Because family members were not available for further
analyses, we tentatively considered these haplotypes to be associated
with the respective mutations. Family segregation analysis in the two
families with apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) revealed
two new haplotypes unequivocally associated with the mutant (ins,
XbaI+, MspI+, EcoRI+, 3'VNTR-37 and
del, XbaI+, MspI+, EcoRI+, 3'VNTR-37,
respectively, see Table 3
and Fig. 3
). These two haplotypes are distinct from those found previously
in one Scottish family (XbaI+, MspI-,
EcoRI+) and in Asian patients with apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) (XbaI-,
MspI+, EcoRI+, 3'VNTR-35).
|
|
|
The lipid, lipoprotein, and apolipoprotein concentrations in those
subjects carrying different apo B mutations are shown in Tables 2 through 4
. The screening strategy produced increased cholesterol, LDL-C,
and apo B concentrations in all patient groups. Three of the 21
apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) carriers suffered from
coronary heart disease, five were on lipid-lowering drugs, and only the
apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) homozygote revealed
small xanthelasmas of the upper eyelids and a mild arcus lipoides
corneae. apo B (Glu3405
Gln) was detected in
three subjects with mild hypercholesterolemia (LDL-C, 1.561.69 g/L)
and one subject with a LDL-C concentration of 2.43 g/L who were not
being treated with lipid-lowering drugs. One of the apo B
(Glu3405
Gln) carriers, a 52-year-old male with
a LDL-C concentration of 1.57 g/L, had CAD. We studied the interaction
of LDL from this patient with cultured fibroblasts. Confirming a recent
report (44), the binding of LDL from the apo B-100
(Glu3405
Gln) carrier was identical to LDL from
normolipidemic donors. Unexpectedly, this was not matched by cellular
uptake nor lysosomal degradation. Instead, both uptake and degradation
of the mutant LDL were decreased to 85% and 87.5%, respectively, with
the differences reaching statistical significance (P <0.05)
at the highest concentration of radiolabeled
125I-LDL assayed (Fig. 4
).
|
|
We were also interested in determining the phenotypic consequences of
the apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) mutation. The two
index patients heterozygous for apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) had no clinical signs of arterial
occlusive disease nor any symptoms frequently associated with FDB. Two
members of the GR-098 family carried the mutant allele. GR-098/I-2, the
index patient, had a LDL-C concentration of 1.61 g/L while being
treated with 20 mg of pravastatin daily. If we assume that this
treatment produces a 25% reduction of LDL-C, his pretreatment LDL-C
should have been 2.15 g/L, which is close to the concentration seen in
GR-098/II-3 (2.33 g/L), his 13-year-old daughter who carried the
mutation as well. Although still slightly increased, the LDL-C
concentration was <2.0 g/L in both unaffected family members
(GR-098/I-1 and GR-098/II-4). A history of HLP on both maternal sides
of the immediately preceding generation was quoted in the GR-098
family, but no samples from the mother of the index patient or from the
mother of his wife (GR-098/I-1) were available for analysis. This
positive family history for HLP may, however, explain why GR-098/I-1
and GR-098/II-4 had increased LDL-C in the absence of apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp).
The other index patient (L-1193/II-7) was a 41-year-old male who had
been first diagnosed with HLP type IIa in 1987. In June 1996, his LDL-C
was 2.84 g/L. Since then, he had taken a hydroxymethylglutaryl-CoA
reductase inhibitor (10 mg of simvastatin once daily). In
response to treatment, he experienced an ~40% reduction of plasma
LDL-C. In the L-1193 kindred, assessment of the phenotypic consequences
of the apo B (Arg3500
Trp) mutation was
complicated because only one unaffected individual was available and
because there was some interindividual variation of LDL-C among the
mutation carriers. The 66-year-old mother (L-1193/I-5) of the index
patient had been treated with micronized fenofibrate (200 mg once
daily) for the last 10 years, which might explain why her LDL-C
concentration was only 1.73 g/L. Her father died of myocardial
infarction at the age of 62. In 1995, she had been diagnosed as having
diabetes mellitus, which was under treatment as well. The two affected
sons of L-1193/I-5, 13-year-old dizygous twins, had low LDL-C, which
was, however, well above the 90th percentile for that age. Furthermore,
it is in line with the assumption that apo B
(Arg3500
Trp) causes hypercholesterolemia that
the LDL-C concentration in the only unaffected adult member
(L-1193/I-6) was lower than in the two other adult carriers of the
mutation.
We analyzed the interaction of LDL from two unrelated individuals
heterozygous for apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) with
LDL receptors compared with the interaction of LDL pooled from
normolipidemic individuals and LDL from an apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) heterozygous individual. At each
of the concentrations studied, the binding, internalization, and
degradation of LDL from the apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) heterozygotes were substantially
lower than normal (on average, 58% of the values obtained for normal
LDL) but consistently higher compared with LDL from an apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) heterozygote (44% of the values
obtained for normal LDL); the differences between apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) LDL and normal as well as apo
B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) LDL were statistically
significant at all concentrations except the three lowest ligand
concentrations in the assay for binding at 4 °C (Fig. 5
). These observations were reproducible in three experiments,
all of which were conducted independently, including labeling. However,
we wished to rule out that the differences were caused by different
degrees of denaturation of the LDL during the iodination procedure. We
therefore studied the interaction of mutant and normal LDL with
fibroblasts in culture, utilizing them as unlabeled competitors for
iodinated normal LDL. Again, we performed three entirely independent
experiments, all of which completely reproduced the differences seen in
the direct binding, uptake, and degradation studies (Fig. 6
).
|
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Gln)
previously had been estimated to occur at a frequency of 1 in 700
(22). Individuals who have inherited one mutant allele
develop moderate hypercholesterolemia; the few homozygous carriers of
the mutation described to date have LDL-C concentrations similar to
those observed in heterozygous LDL-receptor deficiency
(39)(45)(46).
For many years, the replacement of Arg by Gln at position 3500 was the
only mutation known to produce ligand-defective apo B-100. Reports of
other apo B-100 variants (Arg3531
Cys and
Arg3500
Trp) unequivocally linked to
hypercholesterolemia have appeared only twice to date
(11)(12), whereas several detailed
investigations of the apo B-100 gene sequence that codes for its
receptor-binding function failed to detect any relevant mutation beyond
apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln)
(10)(13)(47)(48)(49).
Nevertheless, when commencing this study, we hypothesized that other
binding-defective species of apo B-100 functionally comparable to these
mutations existed in the human population. To identify such mutations,
we designed a TGGE-based procedure that enabled us to search for
sequence variations in the region coding for the putative
receptor-binding domain of apo B-100. We chose TGGE because it affords
a high sensitivity (>95%) for point mutations if experimental
conditions are optimized. As demonstrated in Fig. 2
, within a 445-bp
segment, four different mutations could be detected simultaneously.
Even two transitions at codon 3500, apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) and apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp), were distinguishable by virtue
of the 0.2 °C difference in their melting temperatures. We are
convinced that TGGE represents a valid and convenient alternative to
direct sequencing (10)(47), single-strand
conformation polymorphism (SSCP) (13)(48), and
denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis
(15)(47)(49), which have been used
to investigate the sequence encoding the putative receptor binding of
apo B-100. Compared with SSCP, TGGE has the advantage that
substantially larger DNA fragments can be analyzed without diminishing
sensitivity. Showing that SSCP failed to identify two of nine samples
heterozygous for apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln),
Henderson et al. (50) questioned the use of SSCP as a
reliable method of detecting unknown apo B-100 point mutations.
Compared with denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis, TGGE offers more
technical simplicity (homogeneous gels instead of gradient gels) and
shorter run times. Another easy and high-throughput approach to test
simultaneously for the three FDB mutations has been heteroduplex
analysis (51). This technique does not distinguish between
the various types of mutations and does not allow identification of
homozygosity for mutant and wild-type DNA.
We detected two sequence abnormalities with uncertain pathobiochemical
relevance. The first one was a silent mutation in the third position of
codon 3350, which was also detected recently by Ludwig et al.
(14) and Gaffney et al. (16). The second
abnormality was a known variation (52) that leads to the
incorporation of the negatively charged amino acid glutamic acid in the
place of glutamine at codon 3405. In our study, heterozygous carriers
of this variant occurred at a relative frequency of 1.3%. This
percentage is strikingly similar to the prevalence of 1.4% observed by
Gaffney et al. (16) in a sample of 928 hyperlipidemic
individuals. Haplotyping of that particular locus revealed the same,
previously assigned haplotype (del, XbaI+, MspI+,
EcoRI+, 3'VNTR-37) in all carriers (four subjects),
suggesting a common ancestral origin of the
Glu3405
Gln substitution. Studies conducted
with LDL from a heterozygous carrier of this mutation suggested that
the binding of the mutant LDL to LDL receptors was the same as for
normal LDL. Unlike the binding, however, the receptor-mediated
internalization and the degradation of the mutant LDL were lower
compared with pooled LDL from healthy donors, the differences attaining
statistical significance at the highest ligand concentration. The
implications of this finding are difficult to determine at present.
Pullinger et al. (44) and Ludwig et al. (14)
communicated that the binding of apo B-100
(Glu3405
Gln) to the LDL receptor was the same
as that of normal LDL. In contrast, Gaffney et al. (16)
claimed that the ability to promote the growth of U937 cells of LDL
from nine heterozygotes for apo B-100
(Glu3405
Gln) with normal triglycerides was, on
average, 87% of normal. Our findings are consistent with both
unimpaired binding on the one hand and impaired cellular uptake on the
other hand. A speculative explanation for that divergence of binding
and uptake might be that residue 3405 is not involved in the binding of
apo B-100 to the LDL receptor but plays a role in mediating the
conformational change of the receptor that precedes invagination, also
suggesting that those domains of the LDL receptor mediating binding do
not completely overlap with those triggering uptake of the complex of
the receptor and the ligand.
Among the hypercholesterolemic subjects studied, 21 individuals were
found to be heterozygous for apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln), corresponding to a frequency of
apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) of 7.1%, or 1 in 14 in
that selected group. If individuals below the age of 40 and above the
age of 65 were disregarded, the relative frequency of the mutation was
5.5%. If we assume a prevalence of at least 25% for type IIa HLP
(defined as LDL-C >1.55 g/L and triglycerides <2.00 g/L) in the
general population 40 to 65 years of age, this suggests a frequency of
apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) of 1.4% in the
Rhein-Main area. It is not likely that this estimate is biased by the
inclusion of individuals with CAD, type 2 diabetes, or hypothyroidism
in our survey. The prevalence of CAD in the screened population 4065
years of age was approximately twofold higher than in the general
population. This is, however, not unexpected because we selected for
increased LDL-C. The prevalence of both hypothyreosis and type 2
diabetes were within the ranges observed in Western societies,
indicating that the subjects that we screened were representative for
the general population with regard to these characteristics. Our
frequency estimate may be conservative for two reasons. First, LDL-C
concentrations exceeding 1.55 g/L may actually be more frequent in
middle-aged individuals than assumed here. For examples, >40% of
healthy males and females 45 or older had LDL-C concentrations >1.55
g/L (155 mg/dL) in the Münster Heart Study (PROCAM), the
largest prospective study of coronary heart disease risk factors in
Germany (53). Second, we supposed that apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) is not present in individuals
with other types of HLP, an assumption that may not apply in general
because we sporadically observe carriers of apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) with increased triglycerides.
Thus, apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln) appears to be
more prevalent in the Rhein-Main area than in Switzerland, where it has
been estimated to occur at a frequency of 1 in 209 in the general
population (54), the highest prevalence reported in the
literature to date. The high frequency of FDB in this area may explain
the first discovery of a patient homozygous for apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) in Frankfurt in 1992
(39), when FDB genotyping became established in the routine
analysis of HLP in our laboratory.
We identified two families that contained six carriers of apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp). The LDL-C concentrations
presented in Table 3
are compatible with the assumption that apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) causes hypercholesterolemia.
However, definite assessment of the phenotypic consequences of this
mutation was not possible for several reasons: First, two of the six
affected individuals were on lipid-lowering drugs. Second, there was
only one unaffected individual in the L-1193 kindred. Third, another
genetic factor for increased LDL-C may have been present in the GR-098
kindred. apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) was initially
described in one Scottish and one Asian family (11), and
then became evident only in Asian HLP patients
(15)(19). The screening of large samples of HLP
patients in North America (n >800) (14), England (n =
562) (35), and Scotland (n = 412) (17) did
not reveal any additional carriers of that variant. Therefore, we were
surprised to detect two unrelated apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) heterozygotes, both of Caucasian
descent, in our sample. Even more surprising was the finding that the
mutation was associated with two apo B haplotypes different from the
ones reported earlier in the Scottish family and the common haplotype
shared by Asian HLP patients carrying apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp). The apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) substitutions might, therefore,
have arisen independently in our area. The binding, uptake, and
degradation of apo B-100 (Arg3500
Trp) LDL was
higher compared with apo B-100 (Arg3500
Gln)
LDL. This stands in contrast to the first report of the apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) mutation (11), in
which the two mutations affecting codon 3500 were indistinguishable in
an assay that relied on the ability of LDL to promote the growth of
U937 cells. The reason for this disagreement may lie in the techniques
used to study LDL function. An advantage of the U937 cell proliferation
assay over the classic binding and uptake method proposed by Goldstein
et al. (38) is that it does not involve manipulation of the
LDL particles during the iodination procedure. However, we obtained
essentially identical results when we used the two mutant LDLs as
unlabeled competitors for labeled wild-type LDL, essentially ruling out
that the observed differences were related to modifications of LDL
during labeling. In normal apo B-100, Arg3500
interacts with Trp4369. Mutation of
Arg3500 causes the carboxy terminus of apo B-100
to interfere with the binding of the positively charged cluster of
residues at positions 33583370 to the LDL receptor (55).
The functional difference between apo B-100
(Arg3500
Trp) and apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) may thus indicate that
Trp3500 still weakly interacts with
Trp4369 through aromaticaromatic interaction
(bond strength of 12 kcal/mol), whereas this interaction is entirely
disrupted in the presence of Gln at position 3500.
In conclusion, our observations confirm that apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) is the most prevalent cause of
ligand-defective LDL. However, they also demonstrate that FDB may be
more heterogeneous than previously assumed. This has considerable
bearing on the diagnosis of ligand-defective LDL at the molecular
level. Detection methods designed solely for apo B-100
(Arg3500
Gln) have been applied in many laboratories to
date, whereas the possibility that other variants exist has largely
been disregarded. We therefore strongly recommend the use of screening
strategies, such as TGGE, capable of detecting all known functionally
relevant sequence variations of the apo B-100 receptor-binding domain.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
Trp) mutation. The DNA
sample with the apo B-100 (Arg3531
Cys) mutation was a
gift from Clive R. Pullinger, Cardiovascular Research Institute,
University of California, San Francisco, CA. We thank Angela Eser for
excellent laboratory assistance. | Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
tryptophan mutation associated with a unique haplotype. Clin Chem 1997;43:916-923.
Gln and Arg3531
Cys mutations in a French population. Hum Mutat 1997;10:160-163.
[Web of Science][Medline]
[Order article via Infotrieve]
Trp mutation in hyperlipidemic Chinese. Clin Chem 1998;44:1659-1665.
Gln) allele specific polymerase chain reaction: large-scale screening of pooled blood samples. J Lipid Res 1992;33:1563-1567.
[Abstract]
The following articles in journals at HighWire Press have cited this article:
![]() |
H. Ledmyr, L. Ottosson, M. Sunnerhagen, and E. Ehrenborg The Ile128Thr polymorphism influences stability and ligand binding properties of the microsomal triglyceride transfer protein J. Lipid Res., July 1, 2006; 47(7): 1378 - 1385. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. A. Austin, C. M. Hutter, R. L. Zimmern, and S. E. Humphries Genetic Causes of Monogenic Heterozygous Familial Hypercholesterolemia: A HuGE Prevalence Review Am. J. Epidemiol., September 1, 2004; 160(5): 407 - 420. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Horvath, A. Savov, S. Kirov, E. Karshelova, I. Paskaleva, A. Goudev, and V. Ganev High frequency of the ApoB-100 R3500Q mutation in Bulgarian hypercholesterolaemic subjects J. Med. Genet., August 1, 2001; 38(8): 536 - 540. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Boren, U. Ekstrom, B. Agren, P. Nilsson-Ehle, and T. L. Innerarity The Molecular Mechanism for the Genetic Disorder Familial Defective Apolipoprotein B100 J. Biol. Chem., March 16, 2001; 276(12): 9214 - 9218. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |