Received on May 19, 2004
Accepted on September 10, 2004

Evidence-Based Medicine and Test Utilization

Assessment of Urinary Bone Markers for Monitoring Treatment of Osteoporosis

¹ Charles Salt Centre, Robert Jones and Agnes Hunt Orthopaedic and District Hospital, Oswestry, Shropshire, SY10 7AG, United Kingdom

^* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: mike.worsfold{at}rjah.nhs.uk.

Background: The usefulness of urinary markers of bone turnover in monitoring therapy depends on their within-person variability compared with their responses to therapy. The aim of this study was to ????.

Methods: We measured variation during a whole year of cross-linked N-terminal telopeptide of collagen I (NTx) and urinary deoxypyridinoline (DPD) as ratios to creatinine concentration and after log-transformation of the ratios, in untreated women stratified into three bone density classes, of which the lowest was osteoporotic. We also measured changes in bone mineral density at the lumbar spine (LSBMD) and hip (FNBMD) in untreated women with normal bones and in those with moderate osteopenia and calculated the reference change value (RCV; or least significant change) at P <0.05 for all of these measures. We made the same measurements on women treated with bisphosphonates, estrogen replacement (HRT), or calcium and examined their individual responses to treatment compared with RCV.

Results: After 12 months on bisphosphonates, LSBMD changed more than RCV (2.55%) in 47% of women compared with 44% of those on HRT and 13% of those on calcium. Response of FNBMD was less. Log NTx (RCV= -28%) responded to bisphosphonates in 78%, regardless of BMD, but less often to HRT (67%). Log DPD (RCV= -30%) responded to bisphosphonates less frequently (53% at 12 months).

Conclusions: NTx has advantages over DPD in monitoring therapy for osteoporosis when mailed urine samples are used.